IMBB #15: Trial by Jelly

Image hosted by

For this month’s IMBB challenge, hosted by Simply Recipes, I tried out a recipe for a Panna Cotta Parfait and Red Fruit Jelly from Patrick O’Connell’s Refined American Cuisine. When O’Connell makes this dessert, he uses a tall, skinny glass and layers both the jelly and panna cotta twice. For two reasons, I opted for only one layer of each. The first reason is that I really wanted to use the glasses pictured above. They come from a set of 8 gorgeous shot glasses (consisting of 4 pairs of distinct shapes). The glasses are small, so at most I could have set only 1 extra layer of either the jelly or the panna cotta.

But the second reason, and the real reason I didn’t add that extra layer of jelly (which I had considered), is that O’Connell’s recipe was off—specifically, his gelatine measurements were incorrect. I’m not exactly sure what brand of gelatine powder O’Connell uses, but he must have some super-industrial stuff. After following his prescribed measurements, neither my red fruit jelly nor the panna cotta would set. His panna cotta mix, for example, called for a 1⁄4 teaspoon of powdered gelatine for roughly 500ml of liquid. (I’ve since compared that to another cookbook—something I should have done that day and stupidly didn’t do—and read a similar recipe calling for 1 1⁄2 teaspoon of powdered gelatine for 450ml of liquid.) I ended up having to ‘guestimate’ how much more extra gelatine I would need to add. I added what I thought would be right for each, but I still wasn’t confident that the panna cotta would set perfectly. So instead of risking creating a mess—I had visions of pouring the jelly liquid over the panna cotta and it all mixing into one pink sludge—I stuck with only one layer of jelly below and one layer of panna cotta.

(Aside from the whole gelatine debacle, my only other real variation from the recipe was with the jelly’s flavour. O’Connell uses a variety of berries, but I decided to use only strawberries.)

In the end, my panna cotta did set, but barely. Nonetheless, everyone enjoyed it, and my wife commented that she actually liked the panna cotta the way it was—very custardy and slightly runny. It made, she told me, a good contrast with the firmer jelly below. I’m not so sure she was right, but great wife that she is, she had only good things to say.

–The IMBB #15 Round-up is posted here.

About Aun Koh

Aun has always loved food and travel, passions passed down to him from his parents. This foundation, plus a background in media, pushed him to start Chubby Hubby in 2005. He loves that this site allows him to write about the things he adores--food, style, travel, his wife and his three kids!